I have been reading some Orthodox prophecies and am stunned. Rather than Russia being the 'bad guy', the opposite is the case in lots of theirs as is the destruction of the Catholic Church and the unification of Christians under Orthodoxy. Several expect a Russian government to come to the aid of Orthodoxy in Greece following an incursion into Greece by the Muslims of Turkey. Others talk of Chines and Japanese incursions into Russia and the rise of a Christian Tsar (The Great King of Catholic prophecy??) However one Orthodox prophecy, from Ignatius of Harbin, did 'strike a chord': 'What started in Russia will end in America.’ Which has been interpreted as follows: 1. A cautious and conservative interpretation is that Elder Ignatius foresaw America becoming increasingly socialist in character, in a convergence with Russia. 2. Another interpretation is that Ignatius expected religious toleration to diminish in America as it did in Soviet Russia, perhaps with the result of martyrdom. 3. In a third and highly pessimistic view, Ignatius is thought to have meant that America eventually would become a totalitarian state of the same brutal character as Stalin’s USSR, though still more oppressive and violent. Interestingly Michael Voris has recently said that the Communists attacked the Church by direct means whereas the US government has done so very successfully by indirect means getting Bishops to fail to clearly pronounce unpopular truths so as to seek popularity and being 'in step' with society's views.
I am afraid I have not read much Prophecy from other religions because of the difficulty in Discernment. A key cornerstone for discernment is obedience to Rome and we don't have that guideline with others. Aside from which when you are sitting at the side of a well that gives us so much good, clear water, the Catholic Tradition of Mysticism..I think..why travel? But one area were I believe we were wrong was in the field of Liturgy. The Orthodox ..and our Eastern Catholic sisters and brothers have a rich Liturgy that leads to prayer and holiness whereas ours, since Vatican 2 has been gutted and left miserable and Protestanized. I think Pope Benedict realised that fully in his dialogue with Orthodoxy , a key criticism of Orthodoxy being our eviscerated New Protestant changes. We could go back to the East and learn or relearn a whole lot.
I agree that there is not much point but I was curious and surprised that there are so few of them and what they say. However we should remember that some of the most dramatic and widely seen apparitions have occurred in Egypt (Assiut and Zeitoun) in an Oriental Orthodox context (which is NOT the same as Eastern Orthodoxy, they are not united and never have been). The only Eastern Orthodox prophecy I was aware of before looking at them recently was one quoted by Solzhenitsin in his trilogy, 'The Gulag Archipelago' in which he quoted a Russian monk mystic of the 19th Century who, he claimed, had been told by Our Lady that the grounds of his monastery would be 'whitened by the bones of the innocent'. He had no idea what this meant but it was recorded by the monastery. It turned out that this monastery on the Solovetsky Islands was to become the very first of the Communist labour camps. It was reading about this accurate prophecy that made me curious about what else Orthodox prophecy might provide but was very disappointed at what I read (which is frequently anti-Catholic and nationalist in nature). However the one I quote above does seem to be proving accurate. The Russians just banned the Church, the Chinese took it over and the US government and media (including Catholics) have taken the equally successful means of emasculating the Church by constantly criticising it for being outmoded and unkind - and the bishops in large numbers fall for it, as they have in the UK. The Eastern Orthodox have not claimed any recent apparitions and they generally regard Catholic claims as plots by the Church to justify itself, they take particular objection to Fatima because of the mention of Russia. They also believe that ALL saints are incorrupt after death but if you look at the remains of some of those they claim are incorrupt, they are kidding themselves. We Catholics do have some genuine 'incorruptibles' but I cannot see any Orthodox ones that look genuine to me.
I couldn't help noticing most Orthodox prophecy concerns Russia..fine if you're a Russian but not otherwise. I passed the Church in Cairo were the apparitions took place. There's no doubt whatsoever they are quite true. Sadly I was on a tour bus heading for Port Said and could not get off, I would have given my right arm to take a closer look. Here is another true one, this time in Syria to a lady called Myrna. Also back before the Iraq War their were apparitions in Mossul. Currently there are apparitions I suspect are true in the Lebanon. The common theme? War. Our Lady coming to comfort her children before the hatchet falls.
I had seen Myrna's story which was very interesting. She is married to an Orthodox though Catholic. The local Orthodox bishop insisted on removing the oil-producing Icon from her home and installing it in his Cathedral with a collection box in front of it. The icon immediately stopped giving oil until moved back to her home. Another comment on Orthodoxy. I used to believe that the Orthodox looked to us as spiritual 'brothers and sisters'. When I looked at some of their videos on Youtube and attempted to relate to them, I was definitely disabused of my 'brotherly' assumption, most of them were very anti-Catholic. However they do love their liturgy as you say and don't mess about with it. One of the big problems is that the Russian Patriarch wants to be the 'boss' but, for historical reasons, the Patriarch in Istanbul is the 'first among equals' but has no congregation, being based in a country taken by Islam. When you see the Pope with the Istanbul Patriarch, it means very little as the most numerous group, the Russians, basically ignore him. The Patriarchs don't agree on which national churches are in fact independent. Istanbul accepts the Estonian Church, the Russians reject it and say that the country is part of their jurisdiction.
Just last week I was visiting with a dear friend who is an Archpriest of the Ruthenian Byzantine church. He and I were talking about prophesy and this new Pope. He enlightened me on a few items that he was focused on regarding prophesy and although I knew some, I am still researching others. Here are the scattered notes I wrote...sorry they are not complete. Bishop Nikodim died at the feet of the Pope in 1978 (he was the Bishop or (Metropolitain) of the Russian Orthodox Church The Icon of Kazan went to Fatima Priest of Fatima had Icon and took it to Rome and gave it to PJPII who kept it in his apt. PJPII returned the Icon to the Russian Orthodox Patriarch received it There was a Roman Catholic Church built in Russia to Our Lady of Kazan Russian Metropolitain Bishop Hillarion came and formed an organization UBI ET ORBI in Moscow/Rome to reestablish morality and family values At the last apparition of Fatima our Lady said, "See you in San Sebastian." In Garabandal the first apparition was of Our Lady of Mt. Carmel In Garabandal the 7th apparition was....? Padre Pio said, "The West will become Eastern...." There will be 7 Churches left--heretical ones will dissappear
Thanks for the information. I have just been reading 'Fatima in Lucia's Own Words' and can find no reference to the above anywhere in it nor in any of the other several books that I have on the subject. I have studied Fatima for decades and have only seen reference to these claimed words of Our Lady on this site. Where did you get this?
That is because you were judging them from your point of view. Having lived under the Orthodoxy as a state church and afterwards, I can assure you, that their attitude is described as the famous "Moscow is the Third Rome and the Fourth will never exist".
You are talking about Russian Orthodox Church in exile. That WAS not the same church as the one in Russia.. At least in 1978
Interesting. I hope that you are going to tell us more about your knowledge of Orthodoxy. I spoke to one who (unusually) was a great admirer of JPII and longed for unity under him but another said that the Pope was a layman and this latter attitude was repeated by the Orthodox leader in Cyprus who said, when a papal visit was suggested, that he would only greet him as a layman if he came (naturally he didn't).
Well, Orthodoxy I know is the worst one - it is Orthodoxy of the Russia. And what it stands for you know - the Russian Empire in any form ( communist or monarchist, or regulated capitalist, does not matter) and by any means. Catholic Church by definition is an enemy of this idea, so there is no way they can embrace any other view except "everybody is out there to get us, and we are the saviors of the word" You have never heard about the Third Rome claim? Here it is: The idea crystallized with a panegyric letter composed by the Russian monk Philoteus (Filofey) of Pskov in 1510 to their son Grand Duke Vasili III, which proclaimed, "Two Romes have fallen. The third stands. And there will be no fourth. No one shall replace your Christian Tsardom!". http://www.kimmillerconcernedchristians.com/Unsealings/0049.pdf http://www.ksk.edu.ee/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/KVUOA_Toimetised_12-Laats.pdf
Metropolitan Nikodim (secular name Boris Georgiyevich Rotov, Russian: Борис Георгиевич Ротов, 15 October 1929 – 5 September 1978),[1] was the Russian Orthodox metropolitan of Leningrad and Novgorod from 1963 until his death. He was born in Frolovo in southwest Russia.[2] According to the Mitrokhin Archive, which claimed deep Communist penetration of the Russian Orthodox Church, Metropolitan Nikodim was a KGB agent, working under the codename "Adamant"[citation needed], whose ecumenical activity with the Roman Catholic Church and the World Council of Churches (WCC) served to further Soviet goals. Ordained in 1960 at the age of 31, the youngest bishop in the Christian world at the time, he would go on to become one of the WCC's six presidents.[3] Metropolitan Nikodim is said to have participated in negotiating a secret 1960s agreement between Soviet and Vatican officials that authorized Eastern Orthodox participation in the Second Vatican Council in exchange for non-condemnation of atheistic communism during the conciliar assemblies.[4][5] He collapsed and died in 1978 while in Rome for the installation of Pope John Paul I. The new pope, who would himself die a few weeks later, prayed over him in his final moments. According to tradition, the icon was discovered on July 8, 1579, underground in the city of Kazan by a little girl, Matrona, to whom the location of the image was revealed by the Theotokos, the Blessed Virgin Mary, in a Marian apparition.[1] The original icon was kept in the Theotokos Monastery of Kazan, built to commemorate the spot where it had been discovered.
Other churches were built in honour of the revelation of the Virgin of Kazan and copies of the image displayed at the Kazan Cathedral of Moscow, at Yaroslavl, and at St. Petersburg. Invocation of the Virgin Mary through the icon was credited by the Russian commanders, Dmitry Pozharsky and Mikhail Kutuzov, with helping the country to repel the Polish invasion of 1612, the Swedish invasion of 1709, and Napoleon's invasion of 1812. On the night of June 29, 1904 the icon was stolen from the church in Kazan where it had been kept for centuries (the cathedral was later blown up by the communist authorities). Thieves apparently coveted the icon's gold frame, which was ornamented with many valuable jewels. Several years later, Russian police apprehended the thieves and recovered the frame. The thieves originally declared that the icon itself had been cut to pieces and burnt, although one of them eventually confessed that it was housed in a monastery in the wilds of Siberia. This one, however, was believed to be a fake; and the Russian police refused to investigate, using the logic that it would be very unlucky to venerate a fake icon as though it were authentic.[2] The Orthodox Church interpreted the disappearance of the icon as a sign of tragedies that would plague Russia after the image of the Holy Protectress of Russia had been lost. Indeed, the Russian peasantry was wont to credit all the evils of the revolution in 1905, as well as Russia's defeat in the Russo-Japanese War, to the desecration of the image.[2]
After the Russian Revolution of 1917, there was speculation that the original icon was in fact preserved in St. Petersburg. Reportedly, an icon of Our Lady of Kazan was used in processions around Leningrad fortifications during the Siege of Leningrad.[3] There was a conflicting theory that the image had been sold by the Bolsheviks abroad. Although such theories were not accepted by the Russian Orthodox Church, a reputed original (one of several in existence) was acquired by the Blue Army of Our Lady of Fatima and enshrined in Fátima, Portugal in the 1970s. The image proved to be a copy, dated by experts to ca. 1730. In 1993, the icon from Fátima was given to Pope John Paul II, who took it to the Vatican and had it installed in his study, where he venerated it for eleven years. In his own words, "it has found a home with me and has accompanied my daily service to the Church with its motherly gaze."[4] John Paul II wished to visit Moscow or Kazan to personally return the icon to the Russian Orthodox Church. When these efforts were blocked by theMoscow Patriarchate, the icon was presented to the Russian Church unconditionally in August 2004.[5] On August 26, 2004 it was exhibited for veneration on the altar of St. Peter's Basilica and then delivered to Moscow. On the next feast day of the holy icon, July 21, 2005, Patriarch Alexius II and Mintimer Shaymiev, the President of Tatarstan, placed it in the Annunciation Cathedral of the Kazan Kremlin. The icon is enshrined in the Church of the Elevation of the Holy Cross, part of the erstwhile Monastery of the Theotokos, on the site where the original icon of Our Lady of Kazan was found and plans are underway to make the monastery's other buildings into an international pilgrimage centre. http://soufanieh.excerptsofinri.com/book/soufanieh-chapter9/chapter9.html There are reports from missionaries that after decades of Com- munist repression the Catholic presence had been largely eliminated andthe Orthodox Church greatly crippled. The conversion of Russia, prom-ised by Our Lady of Fatima, will doubtlessly be through the RussianOrthodox Church. Part of the Fatima message is also for Christianunity, so hopefully Our Lady will bring about a union of Orthodox and 185 Catholics in Russia.
Pope John Paul II, known in many quarters as especially devoted to Our Lady of Fatima, worked intensely for a reunion of Orthodox andCatholics from the beginning of his administration. Not as well knownis the Pope’s devotion to Our Lady of Kazan. Many millions of positive thinking Christians are continuing to pray for Russia and make sacrifices. The Fatima Family Apostolatefinanced the building of the first Shrine to Our Lady of Fatima in all ofRussia (dedicated October 11, 1998, with the Pope’s blessing). They alsocontinue to make the First Saturdays. We explore here the amazing sign of the coming rebirth of faith in Russia that has a history hundreds of years old. And this great sign is inthe possession of Pope John Paul II at the Vatican at least at the time ofthe writing of this book. The sign I mean here is the Icon of Our Ladyof Kazan, one of Russia’s most venerated religious images. George Weigel, senior fellow of the Ethics and Public Policy Center in Washington, D.C., was chosen to write the more than 900-page Wit-ness to Hope—the amazing life of Pope John Paul II—while spendingmuch time with the Pope. While at Castel Gondolfo he saw the KazanIcon resting on the altar of the Pope’s chapel. He saw it again at theVatican. He wrote: “My wife and friends were stunned by the pricelessdiamond and ruby-encrusted frame which partially covers the Icon itself.” It is interesting that the Icon of Soufanieh which has gained so much attention in Damascus, and then throughout the world, consid-ered to be a replica or at least one version of the famous Kazan Icon, isan extremely inexpensive reproduction. The original Soufanieh image,which was at the beginning of the Soufanieh phenomena, is in a plasticframe, 2.4 × 3.2 inches. Nicolas, while traveling, bought ten small repro-ductions of Our Lady of Kazan from the Alexander Nevsky OrthodoxChurch in Sofia, Bulgaria. It was one of these, on rather thin paper,which began to exude oil on November 27, 1982, and is still in theshrine in the Soufanieh home today. Would not this tell us that the value of an icon is not, from God’s view, in diamonds and rubies which may decorate an icon? Christianunity and peace will come, not from wealth and power of men, but fromhumility and love in men and the power of the Holy Spirit to whichChristians become open in love.
…The Fatima message, the famous Icon of Our Lady of Kazan, the Pope and Christian unity —all are wondrously intertwined. For years,especially during the 1970s, the Kazan Icon was kept in the Russianchapel of Domus Pacis in Fatima. Readers should appreciate what theIcon is about, its history, its destined future, for it will surely continue tohave a role in Russia’s religious history and the future relationships of theRussian Orthodox Church with Roman Catholicism. Patriarch Alexis IIof Moscow is reported to be anxious for the return of the miraculousIcon to Russia. There are reports that when returned a new church willbe built especially for the Icon in the city of Kazan itself, in themonastery of the Theotokos. George Weigel, whom I respect, has written, “Some will be a little skeptical of the attempt to link the drama of the Kazanskaya to varioustheories of the Fatima apparitions—the saga is remarkable enough in itsown right without further embellishment.” True enough, but perhaps Wei-gel does not know the Fatima connection in recent decades and how theIcon got to the Pope. I doubt too he knows the Soufanieh connection.Perhaps he does not know that Sr. Lucia has said that the CollegialConsecration of Russia accomplished March 25, 1984, requested by OurLady of Fatima and the quest for Christian unity are joined, or that itwas largely Fatima devotees that redeemed the Icon of Kazan and keptit in the Russian Chapel at Fatima for years and who finally gave it tothe Pope to some day deliver to Russia. Our Lady of Fatima said “all bishops” were to make the consecra- tion of Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary.
Mothersuperior7, given the state of the Russian Orthodoxy now ( and for the last 100 years almost) it is impossible to envision this church as the one which not only converts Russia but will ever reunite with Rome. This church's history is based on it's conflict with"evil" Catholicism and it still is the same on the level of official preaching to the faithful, no matter what the high officials ( which one has to remember are also the FSB officials) tell to the media or on official meetings. It is just my opinion, obviously, but knowing what Russian Orthodoxy is an always was I do not see the conversion of Russia through this existing one which is also viewed as a very corrupt structure(which it is) by Russian people. If any conversion will ever occur it will have to be through the Church which has not been contaminated by its service to the state throughout it's history.
I agree. However there are differences between the two major Orthodox churches of Russia and Greece and the Greeks don't seem to be any better and in some respects much more problematical. The Greeks reject the validity of Latin orders while the Russians officially accept them (though it is true that some individual members and clergy dispute the validity). The Greeks have also recently 'caved in' on artificial contraception while Russia 'holds the line' for the moment. I read recently of an English person attending a Greek Catholic wedding in Greece and some of the Orthodox present were surprised that the priest hadn't negotiated and obtained a fee before the ceremony which is apparently the usual practice for GO clergy. It is notable that, after centuries of Orthodoxy, Greeks are so corrupt that they have bankrupted themselves. Presumably they don't see not 'rendering to Caesar' as a sin of any kind.
The vast majority of Orthodox priests or people I've encountered resemble sects in their view of own exceptionalism/messianism and deeply embedded hatred of Catholics.